Monday, 21 November 2016

Week in Westminster

Planning is a matter for local councils and your councillors are the ones who will make the decision whether to approve or turn down applications but, quite reasonably, people also turn to their MPs, when a particularly contentious application is submitted; such is the case with proposals for Top Field in Barton.

I have received scores of objections from local residents; understandably so as the development is clearly not suitable for the site, at least in its present form. It’s important when framing objections that it must be based on ‘material planning considerations.’ What is or isn’t such a consideration can be found on many websites such as http://www.rtpi.org.uk/media/686895/Material-Planning-Considerations.pdf

As much as we all value ‘the view’ and want to maintain the value of our house but these are not relevant when applications are determined.

The Top Field development is unsuitable for a number of reasons; in particular access. As the Member of Parliament I pass on all representations I receive to the local authority and lobby them but they are the decision makers. It’s one of the most important representative roles that councillors have and one that can have a major impact on shaping the local area. I spent many years as a councillor and use to enjoy dealing with planning matters; it’s a real opportunity to get involved with the local community.
  
It’s one of the anomalies of planning legislation that applicants have the right of appeal but objectors don’t. Last year I introduced a 10 Minute Rule Bill into the House of Commons that would have given objectors this right in certain circumstances. I recognise that the system would very quickly grind to a halt if you could appeal every decision to extend a garage or add a conservatory but criteria could be set that preclude these sort of proposals. For example for major developments of say 100 dwellings or more or when the town or parish council has objected.

10 Minute Rule Bills are a way of highlighting an issue and starting a debate about an issue, they rarely become law. That said it can serve to raise an issue up the political agenda and its one that has considerable support in Parliament, though governments of all colours have refused to consider it. I can see why since appeals cause delays and for business developments that can be a major problem but I’m sure it’s possible to create a system that can deal quickly with applications and ensure that all sides have the opportunity of putting their case and that deliver speedy decisions.

I’ll keep pressing the case.

The changing face of world politics carries on apace. No sooner do we have the Brexit vote and a new British Prime Minister than American voters surprise the world by electing Donald Trump and only earlier this week we hear that former French president, Nicolas Sarkozy, is eliminated from the French elections even before the campaign proper begins. With elections coming up next year in the Netherlands and Germany as well as France European Politics could have a very different look and feel this time next year. If outsiders win any of these elections the EU could become very unstable. We certainly made the right decision on 23rd June.

Tuesday, 25 October 2016

Who Would You Vote For

WHO YOU would vote for if there was an election tomorrow?
All the polls indicate a substantial Conservative majority but we have a two-party system and we need an alternative government. Sadly, the Labour party is a long way from providing a serious alternative and in fact are not even capable of providing effective opposition.
http://tracking.omnitagjs.com/tracking/pixel?event_kind=VISIBLE_IMPRESSION&attempt=311c7a113bd4bb3d9d28a102573cb135&campaign=c7c2275b57cc4d7f415825b256afaa86
Has anything you have seen or heard from the Party Conferences that changed your mind, strengthened or weakened your support for any of the parties?
Understandably it's the leader's speech that receives the most coverage and we now have a much more comprehensive picture of Theresa May's style of Conservatism. My assessment of the mood of the Party is that it is delighted and relieved that it now has more of a feel of the traditional Conservative Party, David Cameron can be credited with making the Tories electable in the political era dominated by Tony Blair. Every period demands our politicians to redefine their party based on the dominate theme and public concerns of the time.
What Theresa May made clear was that she recognises the mood of the country and has adapted the Government's policies to address that mood. The challenge as always is converting these aspirations into actions. There will be events completely beyond our Government's control that come along and knock them off course but knowing Mrs May's determination and looking at the quality of those around her I'm confident that a lot will be achieved.
Speaking of those around the Prime Minister one thing that is helpful at party conferences is that, since you are spending three or four days more or less locked away with other politicians, supporters and those mysterious people the 'spads.' That's the jargon for special advisor something that all ministers have and rightly so. The most senior of these is the man dubbed by the media as the man behind the throne. It is Nick Timothy who is the PM's Chief of Staff. I had a brief chat with him on Sunday evening. He's clearly going to have considerable influence so it was worthwhile flagging up with him the issues facing our area. Apart from getting to know more of these influential people I also took part in a number of fringe meetings; one about the Northern Powerhouse, another about the importance of transport connections and one about devolution of power from central government. The devolution debate is of particular relevance to Lincolnshire as we are currently involved in a process that will, hopefully, bring about a Greater Lincolnshire Combined Authority and an elected mayor to pull together the differing priorities from around the county.
The meeting was dominated by councillors – no surprise there – but it highlighted how some of our elected representatives are looking inward rather than outward to the communities they represent. There was too much talk of structures. The fact is that the public are not concerned whether it's the District Council or the County Council who empty the bins, make sure the street lights come on or fill the potholes. What matters is that these things get done. Thankfully in North and North East Lincolnshire we have unitary councils rather than the two-tier structure.
It's the fringe meetings that are far more interesting than what takes place in the main auditorium which is just a series of speeches from leading figures and important though that is when you are the governing power it is on the fringe that the more lively debate takes place.
Back in the constituency after the trip to Birmingham it was encouraging on Thursday to visit two new businesses.
The local economy is still expanding and despite the inevitable setbacks more jobs are being created and opportunities for our young people though there remains a gap in that we still aren't producing enough young people with the skills that they require for many of our industries.

Yes, there have been improvements but as employees repeatedly remind me there is more to be done and I will be discussing the issue with the Skills Minister and the Humber Local Enterprise Partnership who are specifically charged with addressing skills.

Friday, 7 October 2016

Week in Westminster

Who you would vote for if there was an election tomorrow? All the polls indicate a substantial Conservative majority but we have a two-party system and we need an alternative government. Sadly the Labour party is a long way from providing a serious alternative and in fact are not even capable of providing effective opposition.

Has anything you have seen or heard from the Party Conferences that changed your mind, strengthened or weakened your support for any of the parties?

Understandably it’s the leader’s speech that receives the most coverage and we now have a much more comprehensive picture of Theresa May’s style of Conservatism. My assessment of the mood of the Party is that it is delighted and relieved that it now has more of a feel of the traditional Conservative Party, David Cameron can be credited with making the Tories electable in the political era dominated by Tony Blair. Every period demands our politicians to redefine their party based on the dominate theme and public concerns of the time.

What Theresa May made clear was that she recognises the mood of the country and has adapted the Government’s policies to address that mood. The challenge as always is converting these aspirations into actions. There will be events completely beyond our Government’s control that come along and knock them off course but knowing Mrs May’s determination and looking at the quality of those around her I’m confident that a lot will be achieved.

Speaking of those around the Prime Minister one thing that is helpful at party conferences is that, since you are spending three or four days more or less locked away with other politicians, supporters and those mysterious people the ‘spads.’ That’s the jargon for special advisor something that all ministers have and rightly so. The most senior of these is the man dubbed by the media as the man behind the throne. It is Nick Timothy who is the PM’s Chief of Staff. I had a brief chat with him on Sunday evening. He’s clearly going to have considerable influence so it was worthwhile flagging up with him the issues facing our area.

Apart from getting to know more of these influential people I also took part in a number of fringe meetings; one about the Northern Powerhouse, another about the importance of transport connections and one about devolution of power from central government. The devolution debate is of particular relevance to Lincolnshire as we are currently involved in a process that will, hopefully, bring about a Greater Lincolnshire Combined Authority and an elected mayor to pull together the differing priorities from around the county.

The meeting was dominated by councillors – no surprise there – but it highlighted how some of our elected representatives are looking inward rather than outward to the communities they represent. There was too much talk of structures. The fact is that the public are not concerned whether it’s the District Council or the County Council who empty the bins, make sure the street lights come on or fill the potholes. What matters is that these things get done. Thankfully in North and North East Lincolnshire we have unitary councils rather than the two-tier structure.

It’s the fringe meetings that are far more interesting than what takes place in the main auditorium which is just a series of speeches from leading figures and important though that is when you are the governing power it is on the fringe that the more lively debate takes place. 

Back in the constituency after the trip to Birmingham it was encouraging on Thursday to visit two new businesses. The local economy is still expanding and despite the inevitable setbacks more jobs are being created and opportunities for our young people though there remains a gap in that we still aren’t producing enough young people with the skills that they require for many of our industries.
Yes, there have been improvements but as employees repeatedly remind me there is more to be done and I will be discussing the issue with the Skills Minister and the Humber Local Enterprise Partnership who are specifically charged with addressing skills.


To finish where we began; which party would you support if there were an election tomorrow? I suspect you know what my answer would be. Is there an alternative party with a coherent, costed and deliverable set of policies? Not at the moment.

Wednesday, 10 August 2016

New Directions

The political scene is now much more settled than could be anticipated only a month ago; new ministers are settling in to their jobs, most notably the Prime Minister herself who has already met with her opposite numbers in France and Germany and faced Parliament in her first Prime Minister’s Questions. It is at PMQs when the public pass judgement and they saw her demolish Jeremy Corbyn’s attempts to score points and showed mastery of the whole range of Government when replying to a wide range of questions from backbench members.
With Parliament now in recess new ministers will have more time to brief themselves on their new department and backbenchers more time to catch up on constituency work. As for me I’m continuing with the job I said I wanted when elected - ‘Secretary of State for the Cleethorpes Constituency.’
Cleethorpes is on a high at the moment; we successfully staged the National Armed Forces Event, have continuing successes in the ‘In Bloom’ competition and if the weather is kind during the school holiday period the disappointing weather in the early part of the season can, to some extent, be forgotten.
More needs to be done to ensure coastal towns and seaside resorts attract investment and overcome the seemingly inherent problems that the statistics show namely, lower education standards, a low-skilled workforce, lower wages, and an economy struggling to keep pace with many other parts of the country. Of course we shouldn’t look to Government to solve all our problems but increased recognition that these issues must be tackled will be welcome. I have already questioned and spoken to the new ministerial team about these concerns and will certainly be keeping up the pressure on them. 
Listening to the radio a few days ago I was reminded that last Saturday was the 50th anniversary of England winning the World Cup and recalling that game reminded me of how it had some similarities with the recent political rollercoaster.
Those of you old enough will recall that Jimmy Greaves hoped to play in the game but wasn’t chosen by manager Alf Ramsay. Jimmy was a talented player who could always be relied on to entertain the crowds. That other entertainer Boris Johnson hoped to play in the final of the party leadership but events conspired against him.
Geoff Hurst who replaced Greaves after he was injured in the in the group stage of the competition. Hurst had played badly in the warm-up games against Finland and Poland and had appeared to have fallen out of contention but recovered to become the star player with his hat-trick in the Final. In the same way Theresa May was thought to be out of the running after a quiet few months following last year’s Party Conference and a quiet referendum campaign but in the same way performed well when it really mattered.
In 1966 40 players were named in the extended squad that had to be reduced to 22 by the start of the contest so players such as Terry Venables & Peter Osgood were pushed aside without getting onto the pitch. Remember George Osborne who the commentators expected to be in the running?
Andrea Leadsom made it to the final but was fouled and retired hurt.
As the game came towards its end some people were on the pitch thinking it was all over just like Theresa May’s supporters gathering round her even before Andrea quit the race.
And just as in 1966 the Queen presented the winner with the prize.           

Politics, like football, can be very unpredictable each competition usually throws up an unexpected competitor - Iceland and Andrea Leadsom - who after a good start eventually lose out.

Thursday, 7 July 2016

Referendum

That was the Week that was: the country voted to leave the EU, the Prime Minister resigned, the Labour Party MPs passed a motion of no confidence in their leader as they continue along the road to political oblivion, two of the three frontrunners to become Conservative leader have fallen by the wayside and Cleethorpes took centre-stage with the National Event to mark Armed Forces Day. And, just to take our minds off the politics, our football team lost to Iceland.
All of these political changes are taking place and yet almost everyone is going about their business; a few hundred can always be relied on to turn up at a moment’s notice to demonstrate in Parliament Square costing the rest of us millions in police time, but for everyone else the world goes on and, yet again, Britain demonstrates what a mature democracy it is. In many countries, probably the majority, troops would be on the streets and a real, rather than manufactured, crisis, would exist.
The referendum result was in the balance until polling day itself when, as I always hoped, the British people would vote in the way that they truly believed. The truth is that British people has never been anything other than half-hearted about EU membership. Year after year successive prime ministers have been forced to travel to Brussels telling us they were determined to get a better deal. They have returned telling us that they have gained some sort of privileged position, that they have opted out of this or that policy so why should we be surprised when the British people said ‘if that’s the case let’s opt out of the whole thing.’ The most repeated comment on the doorsteps was ‘we want our democracy, our country back.’ It was a heartfelt plea and one that I have always shared.
The Tories in having major figures on both sides of the EU argument were speaking for the electors who themselves were almost equally divided but Labour, with a few notable exceptions, batted for the Remain side despite knowing, or at least they should have known, that at least half of their supporters would be voting Leave. If they continue to ignore the views of their supporters it’s going to be a long road back for them.  
The condescending remarks from some commentators that it is the ‘uneducated’ who voted to leave or that we are all racists is insulting and quite simply wrong. They should get out into the provincial towns and villages of Lincolnshire and elsewhere rather than hiding within the M25. Are two-thirds of the people in North East Lincolnshire uneducated and racists? Of course not and to suggest so is deeply offensive.
I’m genuinely saddened that David Cameron has chosen to stand down but he has taken an honourable course. It’s a major personal blow to someone who has served his country well and it is to his great credit that he travelled to Cleethorpes to pay tribute to our Armed Forces past and present, and as we remember the Battle of the Somme and, in particular the role of the Grimsby Chums, we recall how much we owe to those who serve, both past and present.      
My reflections on the referendum campaign are that, though it was somewhat bruising, it was passionate and clearly engaged the electorate to the extent that 72 per cent voted – much higher than in recent general elections. In the early stages the debate was pretty poor but once we reached the later stages and the TV debates began people became more engaged. What is very clear is that people in this area feel too distant from the decision-makers and neglected.
Now that we are bringing the European dimension of decision-making back from Brussels to London, coupled with the devolution policies of our Government that is being addressed but the new prime minister must recognise there is something of a north-south divide that must be recognised and policies devised to reverse the drift south.
Politics will soon return to normal, the one or maybe two new party leaders will get down to work and, hopefully, those in the media will recognise that it is the Government who are responsible for delivering Brexit not the Vote Leave campaign. David Cameron deserves credit for granting the referendum, delivering it, and accepting the result as an instruction from the people. That instruction will be carried out and talk of a second referendum should be forgotten; quite simply it isn’t going to happen.          
It’s now time to come together as a country, accept the majority decision, and work together to build a better future.

Monday, 4 April 2016

Education & Skills

Last Monday evening I was one of the sponsors of what turned out to be an interesting debate about Educational Attainment in Yorkshire and the Humber. The debate centred on a report from the Social Market Foundation that drew attention to the depressingly low levels of attainment in the region.
Although there was a certain amount of political point-scoring most contributors recognised that this was as serious issue deserving of serious consideration and that the statistics showing poor performance don’t just happen when one or other party comes to power; they are deep-seated and have come about over many years.
The report stated that “GCSE performance at age 16 across England and Wales reveals marked disparities between regions, with over 70% of pupils in London achieving 5 good GCSEs compared to 63% in Yorkshire & Humber.”
It goes on “Regional differences in attainment are already apparent by the end of primary school”. It also says: “Regional disparities persist, with some areas such as Yorkshire and the Humber falling further behind and London’s performance surging over the last three decades.”
Some of the political argument centred around the Government’s proposal that all schools should become academies. In North East Lincolnshire where all secondary schools are academies we are fortunate to have some excellent performing schools, with good sponsors, first-rate teachers and leadership of the highest quality. They score well in the league tables and yet we have, as the SMF report notes some extremely disappointing overall attainment.
I have raised this conundrum previously and in February the David Cameron wrote to me following a question I put to him at Prime Minister’s Questions. He made clear that the Government recognised the problem and said “…the Government is committed to educational excellence everywhere and we want to eradicate the pockets of underperformance where too few children have access to a good school.”
If our young people are not given a good grounding at school and shown what can be achieved then they may grow up lacking ambition. The truth is that from whatever background and wherever you live you can succeed. However hard governments work to ensure equal opportunity background and home circumstances make a difference and one of the factors that contribute to success is the active involvement and support from parents.
In the past the core industry in most towns be it fishing, steel, mining or whatever provided work for the youngsters coming out of school but nowadays you need qualifications even for low-skilled jobs. Around the area we have some excellent work being done by our Further and Higher Education colleges and by training facilities such as CATCH in Stallingborough where I was pleased to visit last week to open their new workshop.
Despite their hard work when I visit many local businesses they will tell me about the difficulty they have finding a sufficient supply of skilled labour. This isn’t just a local problem; major infrastructure projects struggle to recruit skilled people in the numbers required, often have to bring in workers from abroad.
I welcome North East Lincolnshire Councils decision to employ a Director of Skills and Learning. If we are to overcome some of the inherent problems facing the area we must be prepared to bring in top people to improve things.  
Parliament is often assumed to be a political knockabout akin to Prime Minister’s Questions from dawn till dusk day-in, day-out but anyone following these things closely will know better. Not only did we have the three hour education debate mentioned above but on Wednesday afternoon a debate about the genocide been perpetrated on the Yazidis, Christians and other ethnic and religious minorities.
My Conservative colleague Fiona Bruce initiated the debate saying that “Christians, Yazidis, and other ethnic and religious minorities in Iraq and Syria are suffering genocide at the hands of Daesh; and calls on the Government to make an immediate referral to the UN Security Council with a view to conferring jurisdiction upon the International Criminal Court so that perpetrators can be brought to justice.”
Exactly why the Government seem to be resisting referring the matter to the International Court wasn’t entirely clear and when a vote was taken it was passed by 258 to none. The vote is not binding on the Government but it may, in time, well result in a change of policy.
After which we discussed continuing printing Acts of Parliament on Vellum – of course we should. Magna Carta wouldn’t have survived had it been on paper. Fortunately there was a large majority in favour.

Tuesday, 9 December 2014

Autumn Statement

The big political event of last week was the Chancellor’s Autumn Statement though locally confirmation that through trains between Cleethorpes, Scunthorpe and Manchester would be retained in the new franchise to be finalised next year was the decision that would have resulted in a collective sigh of relief. It was the result of a massive campaign. As well as the Telegraph’s highly successful campaign that resulted in around 7000 coupons being delivered to the minister by myself and Michelle Lalor, editor of the Grimsby edition. I and my colleagues asked countless questions in Parliament, held a full-scale debate, Select Committee hearings and lots of meetings both formal and informal with ministers, in particular the quiet word here and there cannot be underestimated showing that Government backbenchers with access to ministers can use their influence effectively. It also demonstrates that if the public engage with the consultation processes that governments carry out then ministers must take note – the system works. The temptation, when a decision goes against you, is always to claim that no one listens, it was all a done deal and so on; not so democracy is a two-way process, get involved and things can change.

The Autumn Statement itself ‎was well-balanced and responsible.

At local level there was really good news for those affected by, not just last year’s tidal surge, but also previous floods. £80 million has been allocated as the first instalment of funding for the various projects needed to strengthen the Humber defences and specifically mentioned is the area in the Barrow Haven/New Holland area. The plans put together by the local authorities and the Environment Agency to increase the level of defences from what is described in the jargon as a ‘one in fifty year event’ will be upgraded to ‘one in 200 year event’ are being trawled over by officials at the Department of Environment and in the Treasury. The proposals are estimated at £1.2 billion spread over seventeen years. Obviously before expenditure at this level is given the go-ahead there is much work to be done but the £80 million is a positive message from Government that the work is not just necessary but vital for both residents and to protect industry much of which is of strategic importance.

There was also funding for housing developments on brownfield sites, and the abolition of Air Passenger Duty for children will be welcome news not just for families but Humberside Airport as well; abolition of National Insurance contributions for apprentices, a boost for the High Street with help on Business Rates and the very welcome reform of stamp duty.

George Osborne has stuck to his strategy outlined at the start of the Coalition Government and we are now the fastest-growing of the world's major economies. It will take a few more months before the benefits filter through with further increases in personal tax allowances and the like but we can all feel that little more confident that better times are ahead.


Locally there is much to be optimistic about with growing confidence in the business community and 2015 will be the year when everyone starts to feel the benefit.     

Monday, 1 December 2014

December 1st 2014

A week or two after Douglas Carswell then the Conservative MP for Clacton announced he was switching to UKIP I attended a meeting with my Parliamentary colleagues I said that 'despite speaking as another troublesome Eurosceptic backbencher from an East Coast resort beginning with Cl I would not even consider switching to UKIP.'
‎
The reason is simple; not only would I be letting down all those who worked hard to help my election I would be letting down my constituents. It's often said by UKIP supporters 'they tell it like it is, the other parties daren't give us it straight.' Well that's fine if you just want an MP who is all talk, but surely most people want to be represented by someone who not only speaks up for those he or she represents but can also achieve things for the constituency.

As a UKIP MP I would be a voice in the wilderness with little or no access to ministers, unable to lobby and cajole them at Party meetings and in the Division Lobbies, unable to bend their ear about constituency issues.

General Elections are about electing governments that have a coherent set of policies. We are told that older voters are those more attracted to UKIP. I say to them; do you know what their pensions policy is? If your children or grandchildren are struggling to get onto the housing ladder do you know what UKIP's housing policies are? What are their policies for transport, schools, business support, support for the regions I could go on, and I haven't even mentioned their thoughts on privatising the NHS.

The business of government is complex in the extreme; you can be certain that someone who comes along with simple solutions is wrong.

The one certainty about next May's election is that it will result in either David Cameron or Ed Miliband as Prime Minister. One of these men has guided the country through a recession and restored economic stability the other leads an Opposition in chaos and includes former ministers  who were in charge when Gordon Brown was driving the economy of the cliff edge.

I come from a working class background having been born in Cleethorpes and spent most of my childhood on a Grimsby council estate, I've experienced redundancy. Whatever background you are from we all want the best for our families and that means job security and an economy that allows business to flourish so that we can finance the public services we all rely on - history tells us it's the Conservatives that achieve this. The election is about the future not the past.

And by the way if Europe is your big issue only the Conservatives can give us the referendum the country urgently need.



Monday, 27 October 2014

October 27 2014

It’s strange how some of my parliamentary colleagues seem determined to hold out against one of the most logical and much-needed reforms. Admittedly their arguments are based on good constitutional practice; but when the public are so disillusioned with the political process then change becomes essential.

I refer in particular to the Recall Bill that will allow voters to recall their MP mid-term if he or she falls below the standards expected. Recall exists in many countries though in many different forms. Full marks to the Government for at least bringing proposals forward though they fail what I consider to be a fundamental ingredient of any process of recall; it is the voters who should be in the driving seat not a committee of MPs even though it may be supplemented with lay members – I doubt that the powers that be would pluck those lay members from the streets of Immingham or Cleethorpes. Most likely they would be from the ranks of the ‘great and the good.’ Most of these are indeed decent, honourable people but for the public to have faith in the system it must be seen to be completely transparent and such is the state of public opinion at the moment that won’t be the case if the Government appear to be in control.        

I made this and other points during the debate and it was quite clear that there is a widespread view that those of us who will be putting forward some far-reaching amendments over the next week or two are growing in number. The Government are indicating that they might support some change – I hope so.

There needs to be proper protection against politically motivated campaigns that force by-elections based on the political stance of a sitting member. Many significant changes have come about as a result of MPs campaigning for changes which, at the time, were unpopular. Public opinion changes and some of these are now accepted by the overwhelming majority.

When my phone rang at about 8.30 on Wednesday evening to tell me that the Parliamentary Committee that had been considering the Able UK application to develop the South Humber Marine Energy Park had reached its verdict and rejected ABP’s objections it was something of a relief as the word going round only 24 hours earlier was that it would be at least another week before a decision would be arrived at.

This brought to an end three years of meetings, lobbying and discussion during the exhaustive process to which the scheme has been subjected. All four northern Lincolnshire MPs have worked together, cross-party to bring about a development that has the potential for hundreds of jobs and help establish the Humber Estuary as the off-shore renewables capital of the UK. Hundreds are already benefiting from the growing number of jobs in this sector, and it’s not just those directly employed but the service industries that receive a boost as the local economy gets the shot in the arm it needs.

It’s often a surprise to constituents visiting Westminster that so much cross-party work goes on; we all have the same aim which is to benefit those we represent even if the route is very different.


Whatever reservations we may have about the benefits of off-shore wind turbines surely we should all agree that if they can be maintained, assembled, designed and preferably constructed here with all the jobs on offer then we must give our support and those politicians who oppose them will have to explain themselves.          

October 13 2014

As I write this column it’s the morning after the night before with the election of my former party colleague, Douglas Carswell, under the UKIP banner in Clacton. It’s a victory for a right-of-centre free market, libertarian politician elected with the help of voters who would normally shy away from a candidate with Carswell’s views. I make the comments as an observation, not a criticism as I can understand why voters acted how they did. He will now be a lone voice in Parliament with no access to ministers and unable to achieve the investment in his constituency that is so clearly needed. In this respect he has let his constituents down.

The Party Conference season has no come to its end; how have they may have changed the political landscape. I recognise that most people don’t take a close interest at the goings on in Birmingham, Manchester or wherever but the Conferences are an important forum for parties to highlight policy announcements and for the leadership to grab the all-important few minutes on the main news bulletins.

There’s no escaping that it was a bad conference for the Labour Party and Ed Miliband in particular. His 65-minute speech eventually ground to a halt without a mention of the deficit or immigration. Did he, as we are led to believe, ‘forget’ these issues of did he bottle it at the last moment fearing that facing up to them would again highlight the part the last Labour government played in bringing about financial disaster and their lack of immigration controls? Either way it showed that he is not up to the job of Prime Minister.

The Tory Conference on the other hand was upbeat and positive, with ministers setting out the framework for what a Conservative government elected next May will aim to achieve; it was a programme for government covering all aspects of policy, most notably the economy – the subject on which all governments are ultimately judged and with the British economy being the fastest-growing in the Western World we were able to give a clear indication of the benefits that will flow from that.

The Conference also allows backbench MP s to discuss a range of issues with ministers; for example I held (another) meeting with Rail Minister, Claire Perry, to again press the case for retaining the through train service between Cleethorpes and Manchester. It’s also an opportunity to meet with business representatives, and those from think-tanks who churn out policy ideas – some good, some bad, some completely mad!

The post-Conference polls indicate that voters did indeed pick up from media coverage that it was the Conservatives who have a programme for government rather than a series of sound-bites with little substance.

Though it’s the Conservative and Labour conferences that really matter, since it is David Cameron or Ed Miliband who will be Prime Minister after 7th May - I ought, in order to be even-handed mention the LibDems and UKIP. Somewhat bizarrely the LibDems seem to spend most of their time criticising the Conservatives who for over four years have been their partners in government, trying desperately to claim credit for restoring our economic fortunes and disowning just about everything else; trying to face both ways at the same time is the phrase that comes to mind.


UKIP, whose policies on pensions, housing, transport, health and just about everything else are unknown kicked off by announcing the defection of the appropriately named Tory, Mark Reckless. Above everything else Reckless wants an In/Out EU referendum and has now joined a Party that can’t deliver it; Reckless by name, but also attracted by reckless behaviour.   

September 29 2014

Ed’s Silence says it all

Ed Miliband, by his own admission ‘forgot’ to mention immigration and the deficit in his Conference speech. You may have noticed that he also forgot English voters altogether by seeking to ignore the big question left over from the Scottish referendum namely, ‘why do Scottish MPs vote on English only issues?’

The last Conservative Manifesto promised ‘English votes for English laws’ and circumstances have now brought about the perfect time to honour this commitment.

On 11th September this exchange took place in the House of Commons

Martin Vickers: The Government has understandably indicated that, if the Scottish people vote no, proposals will be introduced for further devolution to the Scottish Parliament within days. That will increase the concerns of my constituents and others in England that we are being treated less favourably than people in other parts of the UK. Will my right hon. Friend assure the House that an early statement will be made on how the Government intend to meet the aspirations of the English people and devolve further powers within England?

William Hague: The decision next week is a matter for the people of Scotland, but its implications will be felt across the UK. We have a good record of devolving powers, as we have to Wales or, through the Localism Act 2011, to local authorities. We are a flexible and adaptable Union—that is one of the great strengths of the United Kingdom. That must take account of the people of England as well. As proposals come forward on Scotland over the coming months, there must be every opportunity to debate the implications for England.

As you would expect a week ahead of the vote William Hague played a straight bat, but within an hour of the formal declaration that the Union was safe the Prime Minister was on the steps of Downing Street making clear that the Conservatives will move to prevent Scottish MPs voting on English-only legislation.

I don’t claim that I alone prompted the Prime Minister’s response just one week after my question but I was one of many backbenchers urging David Cameron to do exactly what he did by stating quite clearly that the English issue must be dealt with alongside granting more powers to the Scottish Parliament. This is yet another example of the importance of being part of one of the large party groups at Westminster that I mentioned in my column a couple of weeks ago.

‘English votes for English Laws’ is one simple part of the post-referendum settlement that can be introduced quickly and simply. Following from that we need more devolution to more powerful unitary councils headed by an elected mayor. Elected mayors are the equivalent of a directly-elected leader of the council. The Chris Shaw’s of this world should be elected directly by voters rather than emerge from a closed meeting of the Labour Party.

Back to Ed Miliband’s big omission; come next May it is the economy that will determine the outcome of the Election and the alternative prime minister forgets to address it in his last big Conference Speech before polling day.

Though the economy is improving households remain hard-pressed but it’s worth noting that disposable income is increasing. As the Asda Income Tracker published last week states:
   
The average UK household had £173 a week of discretionary income in July 2014, up by £3 a week on the same month a year before and coming close to the all time high of £174 in January 2010.

The improvement is slower than we would all like but stability and prosperity are returning.


I write just before the debate on Iraq gets underway; once again we risk being dragged into a Middle-Eastern conflict. That said the motion to be debated is very narrowly worded limiting the Government’s actions – rightly so.  

September 4 2014

There’s certainly not been a ‘silly season’ this August with the summer months dominated by news from many of the world’s troublespots, particularly the Middle East and when Parliament returns today there will be an opportunity for ministers to update the House with developments and to debate how to react to a fast-changing state of affairs.

The appalling events in Rotherham then dominated the headlines only to be overtaken, at least for 24 hours, by the bizarre decision of Tory MP Douglas Carswell to quit his seat and join UKIP. Why is this bizarre? Because it will achieve the exact opposite of what he would like to happen. By their own admission UKIP hope to win between three and six seats at the General Election and in our first-past-the-post electoral system that is an ambitious target. Though UKIP are now targeting Labour voters the polling organisations are agreed that it will be the Conservatives that are more likely to suffer if the UKIP vote increases substantially.  The result of which will be an Ed Miliband led government that will not deliver the Euro referendum that many of us have fought for many years to achieve and, with a Tory government, is now set for 2017; and for those who say, wrongly, that we failed to deliver on our last promise I can assure you that the pressure is such within the Conservative Party that there is no possibility of it not going ahead. It will happen; but only with a Conservative government.

The other aspect of Mr Carswell’s decision that has not featured in the recent coverage of the story is that it is bad news for his constituents. At the moment he is part of the Party in government and, as such, can bend the ear of Conservative ministers, have access to the Prime Minister, Chancellor of the Exchequer and others who can make decisions that will affect his constituency. All that will disappear, if he wins the by-election he will be a lone voice, shunned by his colleagues and even if he wins in next year’s General Election, and even if joined by two or three others he will have no influence over government policy and decisions whether it be David Cameron or Ed Miliband in Downing Street.

Like many Conservative voters I share some of the aims and aspirations of UKIP but I want the representative for Cleethorpes to have some influence. I’ll give one example; after over twenty years of campaigning this Government wrote off £150 million of debt and halved the tolls on the Humber Bridge. In our first interview days after the last General Election my colleague from Brigg & Goole, Andrew Percy and I committed ourselves to achieving a toll reduction. Countless meetings with the responsible minister, Justine Greening followed, she visited the area and after meetings with campaigners and the business community immediately appreciated the arguments and between us we then convinced the Treasury and Chancellor. The reduction has been hugely beneficial to individuals and businesses. Would ministers had been persuaded to listen and spend an enormous amount of time and energy for the representative of a party with just two or three MPs?


Today the main focus of the campaign to retain through train services between Cleethorpes and Manchester switches back to Westminster. Having persuaded the Chairman of the Transport Select Committee to include the issue in their current review of railway investment and to call the leaders of North and North East Lincolnshire Council as witnesses I'm confident that yet more pressure can be put on the Department of Transport to withdraw this particular option from the list of proposals.

August 4 2014

These last couple of weeks I’ve been privileged to be present at a number of events that are important to the lives of our community. I’ll take them in date order; on Sunday 20th July it was Mayor’s Sunday. In generations past this was a major event marked by a massive parade through crowded streets as the new mayor accompanied by other civic heads, military representatives and uniformed voluntary groups made their way from the Town Hall to the Parish Church where the mayor received God’s blessing.

In recent years of course other attractions mean that people don’t turn out in their thousands to see a parade but nevertheless it is an important occasion for the Borough. I’ve always felt that this event should take place as close to the mayor’s election as possible and that we should make a real effort to return it to the more prestigious occasion it was when I was first elected a councillor in 1980. Clearly the incoming mayor and others felt the same and it had some of the occasions of old about it.

The first good sign was that as I arrived at the Town Hall I noticed that both the flags of Cleethorpes and Great Grimsby were flying proudly rather than the North East Lincolnshire flag which, as I have commented before, looks more like the white flag of surrender which, though that might be well suited to some of the administrations that have ruled the Borough it is not what you want to see for a major civic occasion.

Later that week the Royal Anglian Regiment exercised their Freedom of the Borough and rightly this did indeed bring the crowds onto the streets of Cleethorpes to cheer and support what despite re-organisations and the merger of various regiments we still respect and admire as our ‘County Regiment.’

Two days later I was at St. Paul’s Cathedral to witness the consecration of the new Bishop of Grimsby, David Court. Like all new bishops, must be ordained and consecrated bishop. It was news to me that these ceremonies always take place at either St. Paul’s, Westminster Abbey or Southwark Cathedral.

It was a grand occasion led by the Archbishop of Canterbury, assisted by the Bishops of London and Winchester and, of course the Bishop of Lincoln, was also present. In some ways it was something akin to the State Opening of Parliament - officials appear with fantastic names. At the State Opening the Heralds appear dressed like the pictures found on playing cards such as Portcullis Pursuivant and Arundel Herald Extraordinary. For this ceremony the Ostiarius, the Prolocutor, Crucifer and acolytes appeared.

Thanks to the wonders of the internet I now know that the Ostiarius was originally a doorkeeper who had the responsibility of ensuring that no unbaptised person entered the church during the Eucharist and the Prolocutor is the chairman of the lower house of the province of Canterbury. Ahead of them in the procession was the Crucifer and Acolytes. The Crucifer is someone appointed to carry the processional cross and an acolyte is defined as someone who assists the celebrant   
In the performance of liturgical rites or, and this is the meaning we associate with the word, a devoted follower.

Two days later, along with other politicians, civic heads and the leaders of many organisations, I was in Lincoln Cathedral at a service to welcome the new bishop into the Lincoln diocese which was a very joyful occasion.


The significance of these occasions is that they bring our community together and emphasise the importance of so many organisations and the part they play in keeping our society together and the Bishop plays an important part as a community and social leader. Whether or not you are a person of faith the Bishop will have some influence on shaping our local community and rightly so, it was good to be able to welcome him to his role.      

July 4 2014

This last week has shown the value of teamwork and acts as a reminder that MPs across party can work together for the benefit of those we represent.


On the Friday before last I, along with my immediate neighbour Andrew Percy from Brigg & Goole along with colleagues from the North Bank and councillors from the four authorities met at the Humber Bridge offices to receive an update from Environment Agency officials on the work being done to draw up plans that will lead to work that will strengthen flood defences along the estuary.

We were fortunate that the tidal surge that occurred last December, which was larger than that in the terrible events of February 1953, led to no loss of life though, sadly, hundreds of homes were flooded.

As well as keeping us up to date with the plans to further strengthen the defences the intention was to ensure that we were fully briefed ahead of a debate held last Tuesday about flood risk on the Humber and to again make the case for more resources to carry out the work. It’s estimated at £888 million over the next ten years.

At the debate we were able to present a united front and, as agreed at Friday’s meeting, each of us would focus on a particular aspect. As well as myself, Andrew Percy, Greg Knight, Graham Stuart and David Davis from the Tory side and Alan Johnson, Diana Johnson and Nic Dakin for Labour made speeches and we received a good response from Dan Rogerson the Department of Environment minister.

This week we will be taking our case to 10 Downing Street and a meeting with the Prime Minister; an opportunity to reiterate our case to the top man. Taxpayers are faced with a massive bill to upgrade flood defences and we are ahead of the game in pulling together plans and arguing our case to protect homes and the massive industrial facilities along the Humber.

You can read the text of the whole debate at


Another example of this teamwork is the campaign to retain through trains on the Cleethorpes to Manchester Airport line. There is no doubting that transport connections are vital to any area seeking to expand its economy. Whilst it is not the case, as it is sometimes portrayed that someone sits down looks at the map and says ‘let’s be nasty to Lincolnshire and take away their trains’ it is true to say too often the lines on the map don’t lead to our part of the world; there’s too much of a focus on the major cities rather than the provincial towns.

If we are to win this debate it’s no use just saying it’s unfair and inconvenient we have to provide good evidence based arguments. The reality is that as more and more of the rail network is electrified – which is good - the services out to peripheral areas such as northern Lincolnshire become feeder services into the core electric network and as railways throughout the world are electrified the diesel units become scarce because it becomes less profitable to manufacture them.

As the minister has told me repeatedly – ‘this is a genuine consultation, no decisions will be made until the results of the consultation have been analysed and weighed against alternative proposals.

What we don’t want is a return to British Rail days with a slow and irregular service. Trans-Pennine have shown us that regular interval services with good rolling stock will attract more passengers; they deserve to be allowed to continue.            
          

Finally a quick mention for two constituents I’ve met in Westminster since my last column. Sonia Allen from Ulceby is an Ambassador for Cancer Research and Rolf Sperr from New Waltham whose work for Rotary particularly in bringing Dolly Parton’s ‘Imagination Library’ to NE Lincolnshire was recognised when he received an award from the Deputy Prime Minister. Two individuals working hard for their communities who deserve our thanks.

June 23 2014

Bringing together three events that I have been observing over the last couple of weeks brings together Church, State and football.

I suspect you won’t need a clue to guess that the football I refer to is the World Cup. The State issue I’m thinking of is the dispute between Cabinet colleagues Michael Gove and Theresa May and the Church connection is that on Tuesday I had breakfast with David Cameron and the Archbishop of Canterbury – well Ok there were seven hundred other people there as I attended the National Parliamentary Prayer Breakfast but it was a much better event for that; the Prime Minister was there to hear the Archbishop who was the guest speaker. Incidentally Ed Miliband was also there and more of him later. The link to the other two stories is that, as the Archbishop acknowledged the Church of England does not escape its own disputes.   

I’m writing this column immediately after watching England’s defeat at the hands of Uruguay and, in particular, by Luis Suarez. Sadly the team look like being on the flight home sooner than we would have liked.

I won’t inflict my own analysis of the match as you’ve probably had your fill of football punditry over the last couple of weeks but one message has been coming through loud and clear; we are not playing as a unit – too many individuals and not enough teamwork.

Teamwork is of course essential to government and once a policy is decided on collective responsibility as it is called comes into play and all government members must stick to the line leaving backbenchers like me to criticise or support as we see fit. I always take the view that I must always balance what I consider to be the best interests of my constituency and the views of constituents against the fact that many if not most people decide who to vote for based on the party label and so expect a Conservative MP to support a Conservative, or in the present case, a Conservative led government. I’m firmly of the view that I or any of my colleagues can maximise our influence by making clear our opposition and being prepared to vote against the government when necessary but choosing the most important issues; if you are a permanent thorn in the side you will lose influence rather than gain it and that is not in the best interests of those you represent.

But when teamwork breaks down as in the recent spat involving Michael Gove and Theresa May many in the media immediately focus on the personalities and we risk the serious issues at stake being trivialised. Surely none of us seriously consider than everyone in government agrees all of the time and if they did surely that would be bad for government. Any government needs serious debate and discussion to flush out the failings in whatever policy is being considered.

The internal conflicts the Archbishop referred to was the role of women in the Church of England. After years of debate the Church eventually allowed women to be ordained and ever since has been wrestling with the divisive issue of whether, or perhaps more accurately those priests should be able to become bishops.

Thankfully Archbishop Welby seems to have brokered a solution that will allow the Church to concentrate on preaching the Gospel and carrying out its wider role in society rather than endless internal debates.

What of Ed Miliband? Labours hopes of returning to government at next year’s General Election are growing less and less. His personal ratings dropped by another fourteen points in a poll published a few days ago. After the Newark by-election and the continuing improvement to the economy the Government can now move forward knowing that the public is broadly supportive of so much they have achieved. The Labour team are becoming less disciplined and talking out of turn. Have you noticed how few Labour shadow ministers and MPs are prepared to offer undying support when interviewed? Hardly any, Peter Mandelson being one of the latest. They realise they need a new matchwinner b

April 14 2014

I have been struck in recent days about three completely separate events and how they disprove the widely held views about our current political scene.

On Wednesday morning I read a press article prompted by the recent publication of a biography of Labour politician Roy Jenkins. Very often we complain that our politicians come from the ‘political classes’ moving from the study of politics or economics to a job with one of the political parties or an MP and then eventually becoming an MP themselves; we ask; ‘what do they know about life? Never had a proper job’ we say. A view that, in many cases, I subscribe to but as the article pointed out this is nothing new. Roy Jenkins himself was the son of a member of parliament so too was Winston Churchill and countless others. In the 19th century it was the norm.

On the same day as I read the article drawing my attention to these political dynasties I attended the launch of a new publication called ‘The Party of Opportunity.’ This was compiled by my colleague David Amess the MP for Southend. West.

It features fourteen Conservative MPs, or fifteen if you include John Major who wrote the introduction, all from working-class backgrounds. Perhaps even more notable is the fact that he has already unearthed enough about the backgrounds of Tories to fill another three volumes one of which will include yours truly.

Four of the fourteen are ministers and two in the Cabinet – though when the booklet was launched on Wednesday morning the number was only one since Sajid Javid was only promoted to the Cabinet as the new Secretary of State for Culture, Media & Sport an hour or so later. Sajid is the son of a bus driver.      

The other Cabinet member featured is former miner and now Transport Secretary, Patrick McLoughlin.

All of those featured were state educated and worked hard to achieve their present positions. I suspect that if were to read their profiles without indicating their Party labels you would be tempted to say ‘no they couldn’t possibly be Tories’ but the stereotypes will all have in our minds are so often not the reality. If you would like an electronic copy of the booklet please email me at martin.vickers.mp@parliament.uk


The third event was last Thursday during a debate when my colleague from the neighbouring constituency Edward Leigh spoke about how Parliament should go about attracting people from a wider variety of backgrounds, he said “we need to make this place more attractive and diverse. We have not yet succeeded in attracting as many working mothers to this place as we should have done.”

Edward is often portrayed as been ‘one of the old school, right wing and out of touch;’ clearly another piece of stereotyping.

Bringing all of this together what it shows is that, like all of the parties, the Conservatives need to do more to become wholly representative but forget the stereotypical Tory MP – lawyer, stockbroker, public school and the like – miner, electrician, fireman and the local comprehensive is equally the case. If anything we Conservatives have a more diverse parliamentary party than our opponents. 

One other event from last week was an opportunity to meet Dave McGuire from Cleethorpes who was receiving an award as a Neighbourhood Energy Champion helping and advising those who are affected by fuel poverty. Dave is yet another example of someone giving their own time to help their community. His award was well deserved.  


March 17 2014

The referendum is democracy in its purest form; everyone has a vote and the vote of everyone reading this column will be equal with that of your neighbour, your member of parliament or your prime minister.

It took just under a century for this country to move from only a handful of the population being able to determine who was to represent us in parliament to full equality for all adults. The 1832 Reform Act started the process that was completed in 1928 when the voting age for women was reduced from 30 to 21.

Of course it’s not possible to be holding votes month in month out and as a representative democracy we entrust most of those decisions to either our local or national politicians but for major decisions, particularly ones that divide parties,  the referendum is the most appropriate method of gaining the approval or rejection of the electorate.

Nothing is more important than determining the future direction of the country which is why there will be a referendum in Scotland to decide whether or not to leave the United Kingdom; a policy decided upon by the Coalition with Labour Party support.

Our membership of the European Union must surely be as big an issue as Scottish independence; after all it is an organisation with the aim of European political union – something I and a large number of voters oppose. It may or may not be a majority but the only way to test that is via a referendum.

Europe is a fault line that has run through the British body politic for more than forty years. If after the 1975 referendum there had been further referendum after each of the major treaties it is possible that we might still be EU members. I personally would regret that but the important thing is that as a country it would be with the consent of the British people. Until we repair that fault line it is an issue that will continue to divide the nation.

Last week’s policy statement by Ed Miliband leaves the Labour party policy in a complete muddle as witness headlines in different newspapers last Thursday morning. One announcing that it was Labour policy to hold an in/out referendum and another stating the exact opposite; something that was clearly the result of the Party trying to spin the same story in two opposite directions – what a joke.    

There is no way that the British people will be taken in by such blatant doublespeak.

So why would anyone who favours the democratic process oppose a referendum on such is major issue; and we must assume that Mr Miliband and his colleagues are democrats. Could it be that they fear the people may disagree with them? Or perhaps they consider that we are unable to determine the direction in which our country goes over the next generation or two?

The Labour position is that the Scots have the right to determine their own future but not the British people as a whole.

In the 1975 referendum I campaigned for us to leave the Common Market as it was then called. Since then it has evolved into the European Union. Its aim of political union has always been there despite what politicians such as Wilson, Jenkins, Heath, & Callaghan said at the time. There is a perfectly honourable and reasoned argument in favour. It’s just one that I don’t happen to share but whichever side of the argument you are on it is a decision that should be for all of us. As I said at the start of this article a referendum is for all; David Cameron will have just one vote, and so will you. It seems reasonable to me but not to Ed and his Party.        


February 27 2014

Thursday 27th February: a varied and interesting day. Let’s focus on just one day to give a flavour of life at Westminster.

I arrive in the office a little before 8.30 turn to the Telegraph’s website to see what’s making the local news. Then to the iPlayer to see what was featured on the previous night’s Look North while flicking through the emails to see if there is anything that needs immediate attention.

At 9.20 I set off on the 5 minute walk through the labyrinthine corridors of the parliamentary estate to get to the Commons Chamber in time for prayers. As Big Ben chimes the Senior Doorman enters and in a booming voice says ‘Speaker’ which echoes around and the Speaker’s Procession appears. The Speaker appears alongside the Serjeant-at-Arms who carries the Mace. Behind them the Speaker’s Chaplain, the Reverend Rose Hudson-Wilkin. Rose is a wonderful lady from Montego Bay and her life story is fascinating as many of you may have heard recently on Radio 4’s Desert Island Discs. You have to be a particularly resolute and determined character to come from a West Indian island to the traditionally Establishment position of Speaker’s Chaplain and, as if that wasn’t enough, Chaplain to H.M. the Queen; and Rose is also a parish priest in Hackney.

The first business each day is Question Time and today it’s the Energy & Climate Change Department. I have question 13 just far enough up the list to be reasonably sure of reaching it before time is called. Members often use examples of issues brought to their attention by constituents and on this occasion I do just that.

My question is ‘What steps he is taking to ensure that energy suppliers check the accuracy of meters?’ After the Minister’s reply I outline a long dispute with the company concerned that eventually led to them agreeing that they had overcharged by the staggering sum of £2548 and three months later still no refund. I suspect that a cheque will very soon be in the post.

Then we moved onto the weekly questions to the Leader of the House. My question is simple and to the point: ‘My flood-hit constituents are mystified at why the Government do not seem to be applying for EU funds that could assist them. May we have a statement to clarify the situation?                         ‘

The reply though is much more complicated and clearly more work needs to be done to establish whether we are better off applying for relief funds or not and like most things European it’s not as simple as you would expect.

Immediately after that it’s a quick dash to the Royal Gallery in the Lords where Angela Merkel the German Chancellor is due to address members. As always on these occasions it’s a half-hour wait and a chance to look around and see who is there. Diplomats, peers, a whole collection of ex-ministers; I can’t help thinking about all the experience and knowledge about world affairs is gathered together. I’m behind the Chancellor of the Exchequer who when taking his seat and realising he was surrounded by Labour members joked that he was ‘clearly amongst friends.’ Behind me former Foreign Secretaries, Jack Straw and Margaret Beckett; on the front row David Cameron, Nick Clegg and Ed Miliband sit side-by-side. Ed Balls exchanges a joke with William Hague. At midday the doors swing open; Dr Merkel enters and takes her place on the podium.

Her speech ranges across a range of world affairs but all attention is on whether she will hint at support for David Cameron’s strategy of renegotiating our relationship with the EU.

After the grandeur of that occasion it was to the cafeteria for a bite to eat and back to the office to finalise what I’m going to say in the afternoon debate about Parliamentary Representation and how we go about broadening the range of MPs. I have decided to focus on how we encourage more people with working class backgrounds to consider a political career.

Then at 5 one last meeting before checking a few more emails and the dash to King’s Cross for the 19.03 train. I’ll be home to watch Question Time!                     


February 17 2014

HAS FREEDOM TAKEN ANOTHER BLOW?
Last week's vote on whether or not to make it illegal to smoke in a car when a child is on board set me thinking about political philosophy and its relationship with freedom and liberty. Sorry if that sounds a bit profound but politics must have a philosophical base to build on. This could be heavy going but here goes....

There will be few among us who would disagree with the proposition that it is wrong to smoke in a confined space with anyone present let alone a child. It's also irresponsible to feed children an endless supply of junk food or to smoke when pregnant or a 1001 other things but are we going to make them all illegal?

What about smoking in your home when a child is present? Or is that seen as a step too far? How would it be policed?
How much should our lives be regulated by the State? In recent years as a society we have accepted more and more regulation and seemingly been happy to do so. The smoking ban was perhaps the most restrictive and yet it is one of those social changes that is unlikely to be reversed. That's not to say there isn't opposition; there always is and it's the job of the political process to balance the pros and cons and then decide.

At the root of Conservative thinking as always been the concepts of freedom and liberty. That's not to say 'anything goes' but that there should always be a presumption in favour of individual freedom rather than 'we know what's good for you and will impose our values on you.' By ‘we’ we mean the State.
Conservatives believe that it is from our relationship with other people rather than the State that our values and identities evolve; that communities evolve and are informed by customs that have stood the test of time and are protected by the rule of law. In the modern world the State will inevitably have a bigger role but Conservatives believe its reach should always be subject to challenge. The State is just one part of our civil society; it provides the means to protect it.
Conservatives believe in respect for individual freedom and for the agreements, customs and institutions that flow from it.
Another debate surrounds free speech; should you be free to insult your neighbour? An insult can cause deep offence to some, especially if aimed at family or religion, for others it will be greeted by a shrug of the shoulder. In a tolerant and civilised society we should always seek not to be gratuitously offensive. Sometimes it's hard to rub along with many of those around us but we have to learn to live with each other.

If you are a public figure you must expect to be criticised: sportsmen, priests, or whatever. Much criticism is abusive and crude, some bordering on criminal. Politicians above all must expect to be on the receiving end but even for us there must be limits. It's women MPs that have suffered most; many receiving sexual messages of the most unpleasant kind even threatening rape and threats to family members.

Recently you may remember the news story involving Caroline Criado-Perez
who
 
.was campaigning to have a woman featured on bank notes. You may not agree but would you seriously think of sending her threatening messages? Sadly, many did.

Much of the above is covered by the criminal law and goes far beyond what is acceptable. So we all accept limits on our freedom but
there is a point at which the State becomes too oppressive and each little chink knocked away diminishes those cherished freedoms that have been fought for over the centuries. Different societies will draw the line in a different place. Only last year Parliament voted to limit press freedom - again this was just a little but something that would be unconstitutional in the United States where the first amendment states very clearly that 'Congress shall make no law......abridging the freedom of the press.’
107 MPs voted against the smoking in cars ban but lost; has freedom taken another blow?